Venezuelan crises In no less than two paragraphs (5-7 sentences EACH) please describe the economic and political decisions that led to the current Venezuel

Venezuelan crises In no less than two paragraphs (5-7 sentences EACH) please describe the economic and political decisions that led to the current Venezuel

Click here to Order a Custom answer to this Question from our writers. It’s fast and plagiarism-free.

Venezuelan crises In no less than two paragraphs (5-7 sentences EACH) please describe the economic and political decisions that led to the current Venezuelan crises.
Use attachments below. 9/7/2021 Venezuela: The Rise and Fall of a Petrostate | Council on Foreign Relations 1/11


Venezuela’s descent into economic and political chaos in recent years is a cautionary tale of the

dangerous influence that resource wealth can have on developing countries.


Amelia Cheatham and Rocio Cara Labrador


Last updated January 22, 2021 7:00 am (EST)

Venezuela: The Rise and Fall of a Petrostate


Venezuela, home to the world’s largest oil reserves, is a case study in the perils of

petrostatehood. Since it was discovered in the country in the 1920s, oil has taken

Venezuela on an exhilarating but dangerous boom-and-bust ride that offers lessons for

other resource-rich states. Decades of poor governance have driven what was once one

Venezuela is an example of a decaying petrostate, where the government is highly dependent on

income from fossil fuels, power is concentrated in an elite minority, and corruption is widespread.

Petrostates are vulnerable to what economists call Dutch disease, a dynamic in which a government

develops an unhealthy dependence on natural resource exports, and other important industrial

sectors are deprived of investment.

Venezuela has descended into economic and political turmoil under President Nicolas Maduro, as

its once-substantial oil outflows have slowed to a trickle. Absent a power transition, analysts say the

country’s prospects are grim.

9/7/2021 Venezuela: The Rise and Fall of a Petrostate | Council on Foreign Relations 2/11

of Latin America’s most prosperous countries to economic and political ruin. If

Venezuela is able to emerge from its tailspin, experts say that the government must

establish mechanisms that will encourage a productive investment of the country’s vast

oil revenues.

What is a petrostate?

Petrostate is an informal term used to describe a country with several interrelated


Countries often described as petrostates include Algeria, Cameroon, Chad, Ecuador,

Indonesia, Iran, Kazakhstan, Libya, Mexico, Nigeria, Oman, Qatar, Russia, Saudi Arabia,

the United Arab Emirates, and Venezuela.

What’s behind the petrostate paradigm?

Petrostates are thought to be vulnerable to what economists call Dutch disease, a term

coined during the 1970s after the Netherlands discovered natural gas in the North Sea.

In an afflicted country, a resource boom attracts large inflows of foreign capital, which

leads to an appreciation of the local currency and a boost for imports that are now

comparatively cheaper. This sucks labor and capital away from other sectors of the

economy, such as agriculture and manufacturing, which economists say are more

important for growth and competitiveness. As these labor-intensive export industries

flag, unemployment could rise, and the country could develop an unhealthy

dependence on the export of natural resources. In extreme cases, a petrostate forgoes

local oil production and instead derives most of its oil wealth through high taxes on

foreign drillers. Petrostate economies are then left highly vulnerable to unpredictable

swings in global energy prices and capital flight.

government income is deeply reliant on the export of oil and natural gas,

economic and political power are highly concentrated in an elite minority, and

political institutions are weak and unaccountable, and corruption is widespread.

Dutch disease: An economic illness easy to catch, difficult to cure

9/7/2021 Venezuela: The Rise and Fall of a Petrostate | Council on Foreign Relations 3/11

The so-called resource curse also takes a toll on governance. Since petrostates depend

more on export income and less on taxes, there are often weak ties between the

government and its citizens. Timing of the resource boom can exacerbate the problem.

“Most petrostates became dependent on petroleum while, or immediately after, they

were establishing a democracy, state institutions, an independent civil service and

private sector, and rule of law,” says Terry Karl, a professor of political science at

Stanford University and author of The Paradox of Plenty, a seminal book on the

dynamics of petrostates. Leaders can use the country’s resource wealth to repress or co-

opt political opposition.

How does Venezuela fit the category?

Venezuela is the archetype of a failed petrostate, experts say. Oil continues to play the

dominant role in the country’s fortunes more than a century after it was discovered

there. Oil prices plunged from more than $100 per barrel in 2014 to under $30 per

barrel in early 2016, sucking Venezuela into an economic and political spiral.

Conditions have only worsened since then.

A number of grim indicators tell the story:

Oil dependence. Oil sales make up 99 percent of export earnings and roughly one-

quarter of gross domestic product (GDP).

Falling production. Starved of adequate investment and maintenance, oil output has

declined to its lowest level in decades.

Spiraling economy. GDP shrank by roughly two-thirds [PDF] between 2014 and 2019,

and experts forecast that, with plummeting demand for oil amid the coronavirus

pandemic, it would decline by roughly another 30 percent in 2020.

Soaring debt. Venezuela has an estimated debt burden of $150 billion or higher, more

than double the estimated size of its economy.

Hyperinf lation. Annual inflation is running at 6,500 percent.,approximately%20%24150%20billion%20or%20more.

9/7/2021 Venezuela: The Rise and Fall of a Petrostate | Council on Foreign Relations 4/11

Growing autocracy. President Nicolas Maduro and his allies have violated basic tenets of

democracy to maintain power.

These issues—coupled with international sanctions and the coronavirus pandemic—

have fueled a devastating humanitarian crisis, with severe shortages of basic goods such

as food, drinking water, gasoline, and medical supplies. According to a recent survey, 96

percent of Venezuelans live in poverty, the highest proportion in Latin America.

Since 2015, more than five million people have fled to neighboring countries and

beyond. However, over one hundred thousand Venezuelan migrants have returned

home since the coronavirus pandemic began, often after losing their jobs in other Latin

American countries.

The Exodus From Venezuela

Estimated refugees and migrants in 2020 or most recent year available


5.4 million
United States

351K† There are an estimated 5.4 million
Venezuelan refugees and migrants,
up from 0.7 million in 2015.


0.4 million

2005 2010 2015 2020






Costa Rica


Trinidad and Tobago

9/7/2021 Venezuela: The Rise and Fall of a Petrostate | Council on Foreign Relations 5/11

How did Venezuela get here?

A number of economic and political milestones mark Venezuela’s path as a petrostate.

Discovering oil. In 1922, Royal Dutch Shell geologists at La Rosa, a field in the

Maracaibo Basin, struck oil, which blew out at what was then an extraordinary rate of

one hundred thousand barrels per day. In a matter of years, more than one hundred

foreign companies were producing oil, backed by dictator General Juan Vicente Gomez

(1908–1935). Annual production exploded during the 1920s, from just over a million

barrels to 137 million, making Venezuela second only to the United States in total








5K* As of 2019

† As of 2017
‡ As of 2016

Notes: The total of 5.4 million
includes the most current
data for each country as of
January 2021. Country totals
do not add up to 5.4 million
due to data limitations.




Sources : Regional Inter-Agency Coordination Platform for Refugees and Migrants From Venezuela (R4V); International Organization

for Migration.

9/7/2021 Venezuela: The Rise and Fall of a Petrostate | Council on Foreign Relations 6/11

output by 1929. By the time Gomez died in 1935, Dutch disease had settled in: the

Venezuelan bolivar had ballooned, and oil shoved aside other sectors to account for 90

percent of exports.

Reclaiming oil rents. By the 1930s, just three foreign companies—Royal Dutch Shell,

Gulf, and Standard Oil—controlled 98 percent of the Venezuelan oil market. Gomez’s

successors sought to reform the oil sector to funnel funds into government coffers. The

Hydrocarbons Law of 1943 was the first step in that direction, requiring foreign

companies to give half of their oil profits to the state. Within five years, the

government’s income had increased sixfold.

Punto Fijo pact. In 1958, after a succession of military dictatorships, Venezuela elected

its first stable democratic government. That year, Venezuela’s three major political

parties signed the Punto Fijo pact, which guaranteed that state jobs and, notably, oil

rents would be parceled out to the three parties in proportion to voting results. While

the pact sought to guard against dictatorship and usher in democratic stability, it

ensured that oil profits would be concentrated in the state.

OPEC. Venezuela joined Iran, Iraq, Kuwait, and Saudi Arabia as a founding member of

the Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) in 1960. Through the

cartel, which would later include Qatar, Indonesia, Libya, the United Arab Emirates,

Algeria, Nigeria, Ecuador, Gabon, Angola, Equatorial Guinea, and the Republic of

Congo, the world’s largest producers coordinated prices and gave states more control

over their national industries. That same year, Venezuela established its first state oil

company and increased oil companies’ income tax to 65 percent of profits.

Source: Gustavo Coronel, Cato Institute

State oil wealth embezzled between 1972 and 1997

$100 billion

9/7/2021 Venezuela: The Rise and Fall of a Petrostate | Council on Foreign Relations 7/11

The 1970s boom. In 1973, a five-month OPEC embargo on countries backing Israel in the

Yom Kippur War quadrupled oil prices and made Venezuela the country with the

highest per-capita income in Latin America. Over two years, the windfall added $10

billion to state coffers, giving way to rampant graft and mismanagement. Analysts

estimate that as much as $100 billion was embezzled between 1972 and 1997 alone.

PDVSA. In 1976, amid the oil boom, President Carlos Andres Perez nationalized the oil

industry, creating state-owned Petroleos de Venezuela, S.A. (PDVSA) to oversee all

exploring, producing, refining, and exporting of oil. Perez allowed PDVSA to partner

with foreign oil companies as long as it held 60 percent equity in joint ventures and,

critically, structured the company to run as a business with minimal government


The 1980s oil glut. As global oil prices plummeted in the 1980s, Venezuela’s economy

contracted and inflation soared; at the same time, it accrued massive foreign debt by

purchasing foreign refineries, such as Citgo in the United States. In 1989, Perez—

reelected months earlier —launched a fiscal austerity package as part of a financial

bailout by the International Monetary Fund. The measures provoked deadly riots. In

1992, Hugo Chavez, a military officer, launched a failed coup and rose to national fame.

Chavez’s Bolivarian revolution. Chavez was elected president in 1998 on a socialist

platform, pledging to use Venezuela’s vast oil wealth to reduce poverty and inequality.

While his costly “Bolivarian missions” expanded social services and cut poverty by 20

percent, he also took several steps that precipitated a long and steady decline in the

country’s oil production, which peaked in the late 1990s and early 2000s. His decision to

fire thousands of experienced PDVSA workers who had taken part in an industry strike

in 2002–2003 gutted the company of important technical expertise. Beginning in 2005,

Chavez provided subsidized oil to several countries in the region, including Cuba,

through an alliance known as Petrocaribe. Over the course of Chavez’s presidency,

which lasted until 2013, strategic petroleum reserves dwindled and government debt

more than doubled [PDF].

9/7/2021 Venezuela: The Rise and Fall of a Petrostate | Council on Foreign Relations 8/11

Chavez also harnessed his popularity among the working class to expand the powers of

the presidency and edged the country toward authoritarianism: he ended term limits,

effectively took control of the Supreme Court, harassed the press and closed

independent outlets, and nationalized hundreds of private businesses and foreign-

owned assets, such as oil projects run by ExxonMobil and ConocoPhillips. The reforms

paved the way for Maduro to establish a dictatorship years after Chavez’s death.

Descent into dictatorship. In mid-2014, global oil prices tumbled, and Venezuela’s

economy went into free fall. As unrest brewed, Maduro consolidated power through

political repression, censorship, and electoral manipulation. In 2018, he secured

Venezuela: From Oil Boom to Bust

Venezuelan crude oil
production (millions
of barrels per day)




2000 2005 2010 2015 2020

Price of crude oil
per barrel (West
Texas Intermediate)





2000 2005 2010 2015 2020

Note: Data from 2020 represents the average over the first six months of the year.

Sources : Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis; U.S. Energy Information Administration.

9/7/2021 Venezuela: The Rise and Fall of a Petrostate | Council on Foreign Relations 9/11

reelection in a race widely condemned as unfair and undemocratic. Nearly sixty

countries, including the United States, subsequently recognized opposition figure Juan

Guaido, head of the National Assembly, as Venezuela’s interim leader.

In recent years, Washington has escalated sanctions against Caracas, which have

curtailed the Maduro government’s income. Still, Venezuela has retained oil-trading

partners, and analysts say that support from China, Cuba, Iran, Russia, and Turkey is

keeping the Maduro regime afloat.

In January 2021, Maduro and his allies took leadership of what was the last opposition-

controlled power center in the government, the National Assembly, after claiming

victory in legislative elections. The opposition, including Guaido, boycotted the vote,

alleging that it was fraudulent, a charge supported by the United States and other

foreign governments. Some analysts predict that, with the legislature now under his

sway, Maduro will step up his repressive tactics.

Is there a path away from the oil curse?

A country that discovers a resource after it has formed robust democratic institutions is

usually better able to avoid the resource curse, analysts say. For example, strong

institutions in Norway have helped the country enjoy steady economic growth since the

1960s, when vast oil reserves were discovered in the North Sea, Karl writes in her book.

In 2019, the petroleum sector accounted for close to 14 percent of Norway’s GDP.

Strong democracies with an independent press and judiciary help curtail classic

petrostate problems by holding government and energy companies to account.

If a country strikes oil or another resource before it develops its state infrastructure, the

curse is much harder to avoid. However, there are remedial measures that low-income

and developing countries can try, provided they are willing. For instance, a

government’s overarching objective should be to use the oil earnings in a responsible

manner “to finance outlays on public goods that serve as the platform for private

investment and long-term growth,” says Columbia University’s Jeffrey Sachs, an expert

The government’s revenues

9/7/2021 Venezuela: The Rise and Fall of a Petrostate | Council on Foreign Relations 10/11

on economic development. This can be done financially, with broad-based investing in

international assets, or physically, by building infrastructure and educating workers.

Transparency is essential in all of this, Sachs says.

Many countries with vast resource wealth, such as Norway and Saudi Arabia, have

established sovereign wealth funds (SWF) to manage their investments. Globally, SWFs

manage about $9 trillion worth of assets.

Analysts anticipate that a global shift from fossil fuel energy to renewables such as solar

and wind will force petrostates to diversify their economies. Nearly two hundred

countries, including Venezuela, have joined the Paris Agreement, a binding treaty that

requires states to make specific commitments to mitigate climate change.

Economic diversification will be an especially difficult climb for Venezuela given the

scale of its economic and political collapse over the last several years. The country

would likely need to revitalize its oil sector before it could cultivate and develop other

important industries. But this would take enormous investment, which analysts say

would be hard to come by given Venezuela’s unstable political environment, trends in

oil demand, and rising concerns about climate change.

Recommended Resources

In a Council Special Report, CFR’s Paul J. Angelo evaluates how the United States can help alleviate

Venezuelans’ suffering.

This In Brief explores the critical relationships that Venezuela has with China, Cuba, and Russia.

This Bloomberg photo essay looks at how Venezuela’s collapsing oil sector is creating an

environmental disaster.

Through interviews with Western oil companies, the Inter-American Dialogue explores what

conditions would draw investors back to Venezuela’s collapsing oil sector.

In The Paradox of Plenty: Oil Booms and Petro-States, Terry Lynn Karl compares the effects of oil

wealth on the economies of six countries.

Reviving Venezuela’s Oil Sector: The Role of Western Oil Majors

9/7/2021 Venezuela: The Rise and Fall of a Petrostate | Council on Foreign Relations 11/11

For media inquiries on this topic, please reach out to

Will Merrow created the graphics for this article.

Looking for this or a Similar Assignment? Click below to Place your Order